How to buy handmade: seven questions to ask before you buy. A free guide from Fleurieu Made. Knitwear designed and machine knitted by Angelina Russo, photographed by Dr Steven Fleming.

How to buy handmade: a free guide for Christmas

Angelina Russo

Have you ever paid for something "handmade" and wondered, once it arrived, who actually made it?

I first asked that question in 2015, when I wrote a short buying guide for my earlier label, CultureCycle. Eleven years later, the questions still hold, but the ground beneath them has shifted. Product photos can now be generated by AI, reviews can be bought, and some sellers on handmade marketplaces are resellers shipping factory goods from overseas.

Alongside those changes, claims have multiplied too. When the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission reviewed 247 businesses online in late 2022, it found that 57 per cent made environmental claims it considered concerning, with clothing and footwear among the sectors with the highest share (ACCC, 2023). Australians also buy an estimated 56 new items of clothing each year (The Australia Institute, 2024), so the choices we make about what to buy, and who from, add up.

That's why I've rewritten the guide for 2026. Importantly, it doesn't argue that handmade can't be trusted. It argues that the useful question has changed from "does this look handmade?" to "can I check what I'm being told?"

Seven questions to ask before you buy

  1. Is there a real maker?
  2. What proof is there, and is it hard to fake?
  3. Do they share what they know?
  4. What is it made of, and can you check?
  5. Where and how was it made?
  6. What happens after you buy?
  7. Does the price add up?

Each question comes with a short checklist you can use whether you're buying knitwear, ceramics, jewellery or anything else made by hand. Beyond the checklists, there's a page of tips for buying handmade at Christmas, from lead times and posting dates to gift vouchers and classes.

Download the free guide (PDF, 11 pages)

Why it matters beyond Christmas

Those seven questions point to something bigger than a single purchase. Every time we ask a maker where, how and by whom something was made, we reward transparency, and we help keep local skills and small-scale manufacturing viable. A regional making economy is built that way: one checked claim, one repaired garment and one local purchase at a time.

A gift that lasts

On the subject of repair, if there's a hand knit in your family worth saving, The Heirloom Repair might be the gift. A voucher brings a treasured knit back into use, and can be redeemed until 31 March 2027.

Please share the guide freely. The more people know how to buy handmade, the healthier the whole ecosystem of makers will be. I'd love to hear which of the seven questions you find most useful.

References

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. (2023). ACCC 'greenwashing' internet sweep unearths widespread concerning claims. ACCC. https://www.accc.gov.au/node/95810

The Australia Institute. (2024). Australians revealed as world's biggest fashion consumers, fuelling waste crisis. https://australiainstitute.org.au/post/australians-revealed-as-worlds-biggest-fashion-consumers-fuelling-waste-crisis/

Back to blog

Made on the Fleurieu